Newly obtained records by McAlester Radio provide additional insight into the City of McAlester’s decision to suspend Fire Chief Brett Brewer, which outline a series of alleged internal concerns about leadership, morale and operational readiness within the department.
The city previously confirmed an investigation of Brewer and issued a public statement addressing the situation. However, documents obtained through an open records request show more detailed allegations that led to Brewer’s suspension.
In a March 20 letter, City Manager Ken Wimer informed Brewer he had “lost confidence” in his ability to lead the department, citing both a grievance filed by the International Association of Firefighters and the results of a department-wide survey.
According to the letter, the grievance and survey described a pattern of retaliation, inconsistent disciplinary actions and misuse of investigative authority, along with long-standing concerns about the treatment of personnel and leadership interactions with department members.
The survey, completed by 31 of 39 department members, identified what the city described as “severe deficiencies” in leadership, communication, training and workplace conditions. Responses indicated a widespread fear of retaliation among firefighters for raising concerns, as well as significantly low trust in leadership and decision-making.
Some responses stated department leadership had “failed its members” and was creating conditions that could endanger lives. The letter also referenced concerns about “staffing shortages, inconsistent procedures and a lack of preparation for critical incidents, including fatal fire responses.” Officials further noted what was described as a significant decline in morale within the department.
The letter states those issues raised concerns about operational readiness and the department’s ability to provide effective emergency services to the community.
“These findings reflect deep systemic issues directly associated with the leadership of the department,” Wimer wrote.
Brewer was suspended with pay effective immediately pending further action by the McAlester City Council, according to the letter.
Wimer noted that under the city charter, any final decision regarding the fire chief’s status must involve the city council, and discussions about next steps were expected.
The city council on March 24 voted to hire a law firm to conduct an external investigation into the matter.